I recently bought a boat and both times I've taken it out after I get it back on the trailer I winch it up tight but it pulls back. I don't think the strap is actually stretching I'm pretty sure that when I wind it up it's not winding tightly and than as I go it's getting tighter on the drum which lets the boat slide back. The strap is old and "crusty" but has no cuts or frays. I'm thinking that because the strap is no longer smooth it won't wind tightly on the drum and I should replace it with a new one. Has anyone ever had this problem?