I don't think the clear plastic bowls are approved for inboards by the Coast Guard for fire reasons. Walmart/Attwood fuel/water seperater($27) is a good basic all metal unit. Of course Racor wrote the book on filtration, but will cost more money$$ Good Luck!You're dead-on in the "if it fits it works" arena. I would say that I much preferred the one with the "glass bottom" that allows you to drain the water. Otherwise, you're changing it based on "time" and you don't truly know how much water was in your fuel to begin with. With the "drain-type" it helps to avoid certain stations that are worse, etc. etc.