Re: St Louis area
I live not too far from Lake Carlye, to me its just a big muddy pond and very shallow. No coves to explore and only 7 miles of water from the dam to the north end of the lake. Yaeger and Glen Shoals are good lakes but small, they're like a small arm off the lake of the ozarks. Kinkaid is nice too but again, a small lake. It is clean, clear and deep. The closest lake in Illinois from St. Louis that is comparable (but not by much) to lake of the ozarks is probably Lake Shelbyville. Comparable in that is good size, has a few arms and many coves. Rend lake in Southern Illinois is similar to Carlyle (wide lake, shallow). I have never been on Rend so I really don't know what there is to do there. Missouri offers the best lakes to boat at (if you liver in St. Louis), most are deep and most of the southern lakes are clear. I recently sold my boat, I love lake of the ozarks but the drive was getting to me. I plan on getting a smaller boat and just running around the smaller boats around St. Louis. I would like to go check out Rend sometime. Lake Egypt in southern Illinois is suppose to be nice and fairly good size. When comparing Illinois lakes to LOTO there just is no comparison. If being in rough water is not your thing, like mentioned, the gravois arm is fine for smaller boats and rather large with lots of coves and a few arms, the Big and Little Niangua arms are also calm. From the 35MM on down on the Osage arm is fine too.