Re: Pa boaters
Superbenk gave you a nice list. Raystown is in my backyard, and although it is a drive for you, it is well worth the trip IMHO. Winding serpentine lake in the middle of the rolling hills of central PA. Built for recreation and flood control, so it is all scenic, nothing commercialized on the lake (except for the 2 Marina's, both have restaurants and one has a Conference Center and hotel, and both areas have campsites). Rest of the lake is natural with one "boat to shore" primitive camping area only. It is a deep lake with the deepest point registering over 190 feet deep, most of your boating will be in more than 100 foot of water. Several no wake areas for fishing, sailing, or just relaxing, but most of the lake is open. Busy on weekends, quiet as can be through the week (especially Tuesdays and Thursdays).
If you need lodging, camping, or eating info, let me know and I can guide you to the "must do" places.