As already said, DO NOT CUT THE INNER CORE!
The inner and the jacket are exactly the right size, if installed correctly.
Several questions...
1. Are the inner and jacket both new, and form the same packet?
2. What do you mean by 'and realized the inner core diameter was too large to fit in the retainer where the set screw threads through the plastic shift plate mount.'. That doesn't make any sense. Yes sometimes it's tight, but I have never had to re-engineer anything. Maybe the locking anchor was cocked over a little, or the set screws needed backing out.
3. Did you thread the hole (in the bell housing) and install the cable jacket from the drive side of the bell housing?
4. Are you using the new cable kit 'engine end' screw in piece?
5. Are you using the new shift slide?
Chris......
Here we go:
1. Inner and jacket both new, I believe they came together in a kit but were separate when I took the boat back.
2. Trying to make sure I use the right terms here but where the set screw threads into the plastic part that mounts to the shift plate (engine end), there is a retainer in the set screw threads into, the retainer has a hole in it to receive the cable. The old cable fits into the retainer but the new cable is too thick and with considerable force wouldn't fit through, after drilling slightly wider, it fits very tightly, hence why I'm considering it's the wrong inner.
3. The shop installed the jacked and threaded from INSIDE the bell housing or from the FORE. I've read several of yours and other threads saying not to do that and just to tap and install the new style, however they did not, they installed the OLD way.
4. It seems to be the old engine end, doesn't look like there was a new engine end plastic piece in my boat, however I'm using the NEW threaded rod with jam nut and brass spindle piece. Perhaps the plastic piece is also new and they tossed the old, but I have a bag of old parts so I doubt it.
5. New shift slide, already fixed via set screw and twisty cable to the inner.
As I'm typing up these responses I'm getting closer and closer to pulling the jacket and starting over with the new style cable and retapping the port for AFT entry, but I really don't want to as the jacket specifically was the part I didnt want to do, and don't want to remove the bellows as that was not a fun job.