Re: is a 26" too much?
There was never a 120 Force made that was capable of swinging a 26 inch pitch prop on anything bigger than a 12 foot racing hull.
Like mark said: 17 to 19 would be more like it.21 might work but would probably be a stretch.
As stated numerous times above: First get the tach working, then go from there.
Here is a 700 pound 14 foot hull with a Force 125 on it. It swings a 21 pitch prop. Granted, it is the older US Marine version, not the Mercury lower unit like you have but the comparison is still valid.
You can not "think" the current prop is a 21 pitch You must know. Find the numbers on the prop or compare to a known pitch prop. Can't get where you are going without knowing where you are now.