Hunting versus Fishing?

SmokinBarrel

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Feb 17, 2004
Messages
38
Well, after 27 years of hunting deer I'm finally considering giving up hunting and just start fishing again. So, I wonder if anyone on here has done the same and who regrets doing it? I have a small parcel of land with a cabin that I plan to sell too. Something I worked hard to establish and build up. I figure with gas prices the way they are, I can downsize, and I also don't make the 2 hour drive to the farm as often.

Anyway, not sure what to do. Did you give up hunting and never looked back since? I sure do enjoy being on the water.
 

LippCJ7

Vice Admiral
Joined
Sep 20, 2010
Messages
5,431
Re: Hunting versus Fishing?

Not yet, but its getting tougher thats for sure, we don't hunt much deer though mostly Elk near timberline in Sept and early October, me and my hunting partner are in our mid fourties so were beginning to feel our age. We also fish a bit while Bow hunting to break up our spike hunts and bring more protein into our diets, lots of high mountain lakes where we hunt and a fly rod doesn't weigh much in our packs. We have discussed it the past couple years, the realization that we are nearing the end of our physical abilities to hunt as hard as we like to. Sucks but what can you do other then join the masses in easier hunting terrain. I kinda like hunting in an area where you only see one other hunter in a month chasing an over the counter Elk tag.
 

JB

Honorary Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Mar 25, 2001
Messages
45,907
Re: Hunting versus Fishing?

Hunting and fishing are pretty close to the same thing. We are genetically programmed to acquire food. Most of us in the 21st century don't need to acquire food that way but getting into the environment and satisfying our primal urges is good for our souls.

That is really all we need. . .to be there and do that. We don't kill all the fish we catch and many of us, as we age, don't kill every deer or other game we see.

I would not say that I have given up hunting. I buy the license and I go to favorite spots on The Hideout. I sit with my Browning BLR .243 on my lap and watch the deer. After a suitable amount of time I get up and go home. Haven't killed a deer in 14 years and don't miss it. . .the killing part. I might still harvest a yearling buck for the venison which I really like but don't need.

I fish for channel cat, crappie, bluegills and walleye because I really like eating them. I fish for various bass and esox because I really like catching them, but mostly because I really like being in the places where I fish. I always release them.

Aside from health issues that threaten to kill me every now and then the hardest thing about aging is letting go of activities that I simply can't do any more. No boat :(, no long trips in the car, no more hard physical work outdoors, etc., etc.

Don't neglect your need to do stuff that you enjoy. There will come a time when you lose the option.
 

paultjohnson

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Jul 29, 2010
Messages
1,560
Re: Hunting versus Fishing?

I would take chasin' Whitetails over fishn' any day of the week. Being in the woods is my magic place. Maybe you could just cut back on the huntn'? As long as I am able to hunt I am going to hunt!
 

SmokinBarrel

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Feb 17, 2004
Messages
38
Re: Hunting versus Fishing?

Lipp,

You're right, I am in my lower 40's now but I am still very mobile. Make no mistake, I prefer bowhunting over rifle anyday and bowhunt most of the time. I suppose I am getting tired of the beer drinking deer camp, and prefer to just hunt. My time is limited, so I like to focus on the bunting not so much socializing. I would really like to go back to hunting deep timber in Southern Missouri. But, again time is a premium these days, as well as gas being ridiculous. I think I need a change of hunting area, it is becoming to easy to shoot a deer up north at the small farm.

Fishing, I can be on the water in 25 minutes.
 

jigngrub

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Mar 19, 2011
Messages
8,155
Re: Hunting versus Fishing?

You'll really hate yourself if you quit hunting, and the fish don't bite during hunting season anyway. The die-hard fishermen like me that you see out on the water during hunting season are just out there for the fresh air and solitude, and we aren't catching any fish... I promise!
 

dwco5051

Commander
Joined
Sep 14, 2008
Messages
2,412
Re: Hunting versus Fishing?

Don't neglect your need to do stuff that you enjoy. There will come a time when you lose the option.

Well said. As I am also reaching that point in life where physically everything isn't as easy as it used to be one quote that I try not to forget is "there has never been a rich man on his death bed wishing he had more money but only wishes he would have done things he never found the time to do."

I will continue hunting if I have to hire someone to carry me up on the mountain to my deer stand. My best fishing buddy is my 6 year old grandaughter. She has promised me that she will take me fishing when she is a teenager and pap is to old to drive the boat. My big hope is that she doesn't discover boys in ten years and leave me on the dock:eek:
 

dingbat

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Nov 20, 2001
Messages
16,082
Re: Hunting versus Fishing?

You'll really hate yourself if you quit hunting, and the fish don't bite during hunting season anyway. The die-hard fishermen like me that you see out on the water during hunting season are just out there for the fresh air and solitude, and we aren't catching any fish... I promise!
Ya, stick to hunting. Hunting season is my favorite time of the year to be out on the water. :D

FWIW: Never hunted a day in my life. Don't care to, never had the urge.
 

mommicked

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Dec 15, 2009
Messages
1,700
Re: Hunting versus Fishing?

Smokinbarrel,No reason why you cant do both.I sometimes do in the same day! Cast and blast.If you havent tried Turkey hunting, it is absolutly the most exciteing and rewarding type of hunting Ive ever done even if I dont bag one.Its great fun just to call and have them respond.The suspense is unreal as you hear them come closer and wonder if and when he may appear or come close enough for a shot.They are hard to outsmart most of the time.and being in the woods in spring is nice also.Ive deer hunted for 30 yrs. and enjoy it alot but turkey hunting is far more enjoyable IMO.Sometimes I hunt turkey in the morning,fish a little in mid day and hunt again in the afternoon as some of the lakes here have public game lands bordering them.
 

jigngrub

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Mar 19, 2011
Messages
8,155
Re: Hunting versus Fishing?

Smokinbarrel,No reason why you cant do both.I sometimes do in the same day! Cast and blast.If you havent tried Turkey hunting, it is absolutly the most exciteing and rewarding type of hunting Ive ever done even if I dont bag one.Its great fun just to call and have them respond.The suspense is unreal as you hear them come closer and wonder if and when he may appear or come close enough for a shot.They are hard to outsmart most of the time.and being in the woods in spring is nice also.Ive deer hunted for 30 yrs. and enjoy it alot but turkey hunting is far more enjoyable IMO.Sometimes I hunt turkey in the morning,fish a little in mid day and hunt again in the afternoon as some of the lakes here have public game lands bordering them.

You really shouldn't waste your time with fishing... I'm sure you miss 3 or 4 big Gobblers when you're out fishin'... you'll be much happier huntin' all the time, it's much more rewarding!:p
 

1980Galaxy

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Apr 11, 2009
Messages
339
Re: Hunting versus Fishing?

You'll really hate yourself if you quit hunting, and the fish don't bite during hunting season anyway. The die-hard fishermen like me that you see out on the water during hunting season are just out there for the fresh air and solitude, and we aren't catching any fish... I promise!

speak for youself. I catch fish anytime of the year...

and how is an argument about fishing losing to hunting on a BOATING forum???!!! Hunting isn't worth it in my opinion. Kick back with a beer and a pole and enjoy the outdoors that way instead of freezing in a deer stand waiting hours just to see a buck (and then waiting another year to do it again).
 

mommicked

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Dec 15, 2009
Messages
1,700
Re: Hunting versus Fishing?

I believe Jigngrub is infering that he wished more people would hunt so he could have the fish to himself!!:pI frequently hunt deer and turkey from my boat and take some fishing gear if I decide to fish too.Ive found alot of gobblers calling while fishing and when I get a deer I drag it to the closest shore/or bank and bring the boat to it,saves my back!!
 

MTboatguy

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Jul 8, 2010
Messages
8,988
Re: Hunting versus Fishing?

Why, does it have to be an either or, I hunt and have since I was 8 years old, that was close to 50 years ago, I also fish, and learned that close to 45 years ago, I don't understand why there is a question, I enjoy the bounty of harvest every single time. 90% of the meat my wife and I eat is hunted or fished..it has made a big difference in our lives to have that ability..I would give neither up...
 

mt_bulldawg

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Jun 18, 2008
Messages
37
Re: Hunting versus Fishing?

We have a distinct advantage, MTboatguy. Living in Montana vs. living in St. Louis area - we can be hunting or fishing within 25 minutes - or at least most of us can. I'll do both - pushing 50 in another 6 weeks, and I can't get around in the hills like I used to due to bad knees and a bad ankle, but I still get out there and do some walking. Often will throw in lightweight spinning rod and fly rod - if hunting sucks, I'll fish......
 

mommicked

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Dec 15, 2009
Messages
1,700
Re: Hunting versus Fishing?

My father stopped deer and duck hunting about thirty years ago,right after he taught me the basics.I and my brother tried to get him to join us over the yrs. but he was always too busy,or had other plans(fishing).Just this year at 71 he started back sometimes taking my 7 yr old nephew in a ground blind and a ladder stand we set up for him.He bagged two this year and ill never forget his excitement when he called to tell me he got one!We squirrel hunted together after deer season and when I approched him at the end of the day he had four fat ones layed out on a rock beside his seat proudly displayed w a big smile!Ironically This is the first year in 30 that I didnt kill a deer!Too busy,work,Too hot,bad weather etc.(poor excuses I know).I let 3 walk (yearlings) thinking I could do better,and couldnt get good shots at several I would have taken.I think I went 9 times.Never got to go with dad for deer though.The bug has bit him and he even bought an electronic Coyote call! Im gonna hafta take him Turkey huntin if his heart can stand it!!If you want to hunt do it, if not Its no fun and failure is more possible IMO.I would hate to get rid of my options if I could only hunt one place though.Tough call:confused:
 

bouttime007

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Apr 21, 2007
Messages
546
Re: Hunting versus Fishing?

I gave up on hunting many moons ago, and I never missed it one bit.

Fishing is my drug, and I can get out into the woods with nature just as easy as if I had a rifle.
 

Mel Taylor

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Jun 25, 2009
Messages
489
Re: Hunting versus Fishing?

Where you are located may make a lot of difference. I'm 73 years old and I've gradually given up hunting over the past ten or twelve years, doing less of it year by year until I finally gave it up all together a couple of years ago. Not because I couldn't hack it any more, and rifle hunting in the mountains of New Mexico means, for me, lots of walking and lots of work packing out the meat sometimes. I can still hack the walking and work involved in killing a deer or an elk but somehow, the thrill is gone. I don't need the meat like I did 40 or 50 years ago and I never have been a fan of just killing a animal for the bragging rights. So, I gave it up. Do I miss it? No, not at all. BUT, the difference is that I live in Southern New Mexico. I can fish nearly all year round. And, I have a house on a lake in Sonora, Mexico in a location where the thermometer seldom hits freezing in the winter even at night and even in the coldest part of the winter. I make at least two or three trips of trips there every year for a week or ten days each time.

I'm originally from St. Louis (actually, I was born in Fornfelt, now Scott City, in Southeast Missouri) but moved to New Mexico when I was a kid. But, I remember the Missouri winters and I'll bet that even with whatever climate change is taking place, they can still be long and fierce. What else will you do in the winter if you aren't hunting or at least planning a hunt?

Having said all that, as far as I'm concerned bass fishing is hunting. Just a different kind of hunting. And, I work at it nearly as hard as I ever did elk or deer hunting. Incidentally, I have friend, much younger than me who gave up hunting and took up wild life photography. He no longer has to worry about seasons and bag limits and has even made a little money at it.

Good luck on whatever you decide.
 

paultjohnson

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Jul 29, 2010
Messages
1,560
Re: Hunting versus Fishing?

I would love to combine the two ,Hunting and fishn. I think it would be a kick in the shorts to ride along in a boat with a shotgun and blast away at the invasive asian flying carp.!!!. Here, hold my beer.
 

mommicked

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Dec 15, 2009
Messages
1,700
Re: Hunting versus Fishing?

What a tournament that would be. I can see it now, on TV!!!!No weigh in # of confirmed hits would win.I bet a guide service would be booked for years!Please use steel or other non lead shot though.
 

eavega

Lieutenant
Joined
Apr 29, 2008
Messages
1,377
Re: Hunting versus Fishing?

Don't neglect your need to do stuff that you enjoy. There will come a time when you lose the option.

Amen, JB. I see it in my Father. In his youth he would spend most of his time traipsing over mountains and swimming in streams in rural Cuba. When he came to the States he settled down in Miami and got married. His focus was on providing for my sisters and I, and left very little time for pursuit of his own leisure activities (didn't help that mom didn't care for the outdoor type activities; camping, fishing, etc). When he finally got time again, he was diagnosed with Parkinsons Disease. He always wanted a boat so he could go fishing, but again between mom not caring for that kind of activity and our financial situation making it near impossible he was never able to fulfill that particular desire. Now he keeps talking about buying a boat, and I have to talk him down because he can't handle a boat by himself, and can't find a consistent boating partner to go with him (we live almost 800 miles apart).
Whenever he gets down about what he can't do anymore because of his disease, I tell him that living with Parkinsons is better than the alternative, and that he has to find pleasure in the things he can still do. Inside, though it tears me up knowing the things he would love to do and just can't anymore. I'm committed to not putting off what I enjoy doing now (within reason) believing that I can do it later on in life. Tomorrow is promised to no one.

Rgds
 
Top