Achieving way less or more wot rpm usually results when going from factory delivered OEM props to other brand props. If with new Solas prop only achieved just 5 K wot revs as loaded provided that engine runs strong and tach its doing his homework right need to drop some pitch sizes, say to a 10 pitch while maintaining same brand model, test and check if engine has increased its wot rpm range towards max wot range. Or re pitch new prop at a prop shop from 12 to a 10 pitch one and test.
It's much easier to dial top prop performance while maintaining same prop brand playing with just pitches on second try than going per other prop brands as in your case. Seems will need a third prop try if a 10 pitch doesn't work as expected.
IF OEM prop was revving fully to max 5.8 K wot revs, why needed a new Solas prop with same pitch for ?
Happy Boating