What size of 3-blade prop do you use today? Is that prop's pitch properly matched for its WOT RPMs?
If 3-blade is optimal for your current setup, then "rule of thumb" is to go 1 less pitch for a 4 blade replacement.
However...
Some prop brands have a slight cup on their 4 blades. Thus, best to go -2 pitch lower. For example, I find solars aluminum brand has a slight cup on their 4 blade design. Thus, I went -2 pitch when going from 3 blade to 4 blade (when using a 4-blade solars amita aluminum prop). re: 17 3-bade down to 15 4-blade - for my Johnson 115 V4.
Hope this helps....