A lot of 4 cycle outboards specify a FC-W rated oil. I am not sure Rotella meets this spec. I would follow the OEM recommendation and buy the oil that meets their spec. I doubt the brand name makes any difference, but likely the rating makes all the difference.
For example, I/O engines require either a straight weight 30 or 40 motor oil, or a marine grade oil like Quicksilver 25W-40, which is much different than automotive multi-viscosity oil.
Remember, boat motors of all kinds have a very heavy workload compared with road vehicles.