Just a good all around prop??
There should be some markings somewhere on the prop you already have?
Look under the nut and along the sides of the hub?
Always include the year as the later props were Mercury and are different.
The motor should run about 52-5500 rpm's at wide open, that's with the motor trimmed up
and the boat not overloaded.
If you can't find a number on the prop?
You can get yours reconditioned and ask them for the pitch when it's repaired?
Then start with a 19p and see how the rpm's are?
The right prop can make a big difference in performance and economy.
Had 17p on my twin 88/85hp
I wanted a lot more speed.
Changed to 19p and got more, about 3mph more and about 20% more fuel usage.