The difference between prop and crank ratings depends on the individual motor, and in some the difference isn't that great. 10% if that. One thing to remember, a newer motor weighs a bunch more, so it may have a few more ponies, but that is offset by the additional weight. I can guarantee my 270 pound 125 horse 69 merc would be faster than a new 125 horse at twice the weight. That 68 85 horse would need to be replaced with something close to 100 horse to offset the increased weight if you are looking for similar performance. Since you don't know what the performance is, you will have to guess. Also, you need to look at your total weight capacity. If you stick a new heavy motor on that is the same power, your load carrying ability will drop due to the increased weight.


The hull design plays a part in safety and handling as well. If it is a flat hull skiff, it will be less stable in hard turns and rough water than one with any kind of V (deadrise) to it. I would try to get the most power you can afford that allows a good compromise between safety, economy, capacity, and fun factor. Good luck....