I have a new 40 HP 4 stroke Mercury bigfoot engine on a 18" Tracker Baby Bass Buggy and was out this weekend 6 miles out in the gulf on a calm day and on the way back at just under full throttle the prop spun. I immediately tilted the motor to see if I had caught a crab trap or wrapped something but the prop was clean. I was able to limp back in at 1/4 throttle and when I got in pulled the prop. There was nothing wrapped behind the prop and no damage to the prop at all. Could it be that the prop is not strong enough for the weight of a pontoon boat in the gulf? Any other ideas or thoughts?