nathanhooper
Petty Officer 2nd Class
- Joined
- Apr 21, 2010
- Messages
- 176
So here is the story. This may be a little long, but it will help to understand the issue I am faced with. I am looking for advice, what ever it may be. Those of you who have gone through this, and even if you have not. I just need to make a decision on what to do.
So last year my wife and I had a mini-van that ran, but was running ruff. I am not a car mechanic by any means, but I do know my way around an engine. I personally do not like cars because they are much bigger, heavier, and more complicated that small engines. Yes, I do understand the difference between 2 stroke and 4 stroke, so that helps with working on outboards.
So the story goes that we no longer needed the van, it was paid for, and so instead of trying to fix it up and sell it, I decided I might try to trade for a boat that I could fix up. It is smaller, I could tinker with it as I had time, and so on and so forth. Low and behold there was a guy that needed a minivan for his wife, and just so happened to have a boat for trade. I thought what the heck.
Went over to his house, well, not his house, but where he had the boat stored. And we looked it over. It needed some work, but it had real potential. The outboard looked good, but not being real familiar, I did not know what to look for. Boy do I wish I knew of this site before I had made a decision.
After deciding the boat would be worth fixing up, we turned our attention to the outboard. He assured me it ran, saying that he had it out on the lake not too long ago. He also said that he had just bought a new/used lower unit for it and was still under warranty. Just to make sure it ran he fired it up for a sec and then shut it off. I know at this point that doing that is not good on the engine, but I did not think of that then, and it was seriously only for a sec or two. But I am not claiming any excuses for my stupidity.
Knowing that it started and ran was usually half the battle when it comes to two strokes, made me decide that even if it needed a water pump, fuel pump, plugs, etc., that it would be worth the trade. So out of pure blindness, and ignorance of what to look for, we made the trade.
Took it down to the lake later that day and could not get the thing to run. lol. I was really second guessing my decision. I know at this point that most people would be calling the guy up and demanding that he trade back. But knowing what I might be getting into, I did not. I also know that if I was wanting to check it more I should have before I signed paper work, and bought the boat "as is". I would like to say that I am a man of my word even when others are not. Even though I know I screw up on that at times.
I then decide I will bring it back home and do some deeper looking before I jump to any decisions. I start with sticking a hose on it and starting it up. It starts but then dies. I see water coming out the exhaust, so I feel pretty good about the pump. However, not knowing why it died, I try starting it again. Will not start. After a little bit of checking I come to the conclusion that it is the fuel pump that is not working, because if I take the time to go and prime the carb bowls before trying to start it, it will then start until it runs out of fuel.
Simple enough I thought, I will just order a fuel pump kit, half way expected to have to do that anyways. But, knowing I would be ordering parts, I decided to look at the lower unit. Under close inspection, I notice it is taking on water. Long story short, I order a seal kit for it. I went through the process of taking it back to the place where he had purchased it, seeing how he said it was still under warranty. Which, it was, but they were really lousy people, and it sat long enough "before they could get to it" until it ran out of warranty. However, they said they would honor their warranty, but upon removing the prop they saw fishing line and said that they would not do any more with out payment. Not wanting to fight with them about it I just took the boat home and parked it.
That brings me to this year. I ordered the parts to fix the fuel pump and lower unit last year. Too disgusted with the whole ordeal, I did not even touch it until this spring. I first decided to tackle the lower unit. Did that this last weekend, took it all apart, replaced all the seals, water pump looks good, put her back together and fill with oil. I felt, still feel, confident with it at this point. So with that under my belt I dive into the fuel pump.
That brings me to yesterday. I took the fuel pump apart on Tuesday, noticed that the valves were not working, and one was completely broke, and got on here to ask some questions. Upon looking harder at the situation, and the different posts on here, I decided while I was at it, I had better check the thermostat. That brings me to last night and my quandary.
Hope your still with me at this point. I did not get home till after dark, but I have a work light I used to take the bolts out of the cylinder head and cylinder head cover, which is necessary to take both off to get to the thermostat. Well, just the cover has to be taken off, but in order to take it off, you remove all bolts holding the head on. So they both wind up coming off.
Upon removing the bolts I was noticing that they were corroded at the point where they were in contact with the cylinder head gasket. I thought that it was odd, seeing how the gasket should keep any water away from them, and it was only at that point they were like that. They came out alright though. After that I took the head and cover into the shop to take the cover off to get the thermostat out. After I broke one, of three, of the bolt heads off, I realized that they were corroded also, just a lot more. It was obvious that the head had come off the block, but the cover had not ever come off the head, because the original paint had not been broken from the cover and seal.
I am not too concerned about the bolts, I have removed ones like that before. What concerns me is that when I thought "hey, I'll go look at the cylinders while I got the head off", I did go look, and was sickened by the sight.
What I saw was disgusting. It was dark, but I do not think it is going to look any better in the light when I get home tonight. One cylinder looked good, the middle looked rough, and the bottom looked different than the first two. I will hopefully get some pictures to show soon. The cylinder that concerned me the most (they all do to a degree) was the middle one. It had a few large gouges down the wall running front to back. They were deep enough to catch my finger nails in them.
The reason I make the distinction about them running front to back is because there were others that seemed like, though I cannot say for sure, but they seemed like someone had rotated the drive shaft to bring the piston down as far as they could, for each cylinder, and one by one tried to "hone" the cylinder. The reason I say that is that there are "scratches" that run in a very, very irregular circular direction around the top 1/4th of the cylinders.
So that is where I am at. I am not sure if I should just replace what I have right now, put it back together, and run it like it is until I have time to fix it. It did start and run, But I am willing to bet that it will not have the power of a good cylinder. I am not too concerned with that though at this point. I just want something that will push the boat on the lake to fish with.
My other option is to take it like it is and work on it like it should be. I feel like it is fixable, but I do not know if it is worth the time. If someone has had this issue before I am all ears. Is it worth fixing? What else is there to look for? So on and so forth. Please lay it out for me and let me know what your advice is on this. I think I have covered the questions that may arise, but if not, if there is something else that would help to better give advice, please ask and I will find the information for you.
Thanks guys, I know that there is a world of wisdom on this forum, just hoping that you will impart some on me.
So last year my wife and I had a mini-van that ran, but was running ruff. I am not a car mechanic by any means, but I do know my way around an engine. I personally do not like cars because they are much bigger, heavier, and more complicated that small engines. Yes, I do understand the difference between 2 stroke and 4 stroke, so that helps with working on outboards.
So the story goes that we no longer needed the van, it was paid for, and so instead of trying to fix it up and sell it, I decided I might try to trade for a boat that I could fix up. It is smaller, I could tinker with it as I had time, and so on and so forth. Low and behold there was a guy that needed a minivan for his wife, and just so happened to have a boat for trade. I thought what the heck.
Went over to his house, well, not his house, but where he had the boat stored. And we looked it over. It needed some work, but it had real potential. The outboard looked good, but not being real familiar, I did not know what to look for. Boy do I wish I knew of this site before I had made a decision.
After deciding the boat would be worth fixing up, we turned our attention to the outboard. He assured me it ran, saying that he had it out on the lake not too long ago. He also said that he had just bought a new/used lower unit for it and was still under warranty. Just to make sure it ran he fired it up for a sec and then shut it off. I know at this point that doing that is not good on the engine, but I did not think of that then, and it was seriously only for a sec or two. But I am not claiming any excuses for my stupidity.
Knowing that it started and ran was usually half the battle when it comes to two strokes, made me decide that even if it needed a water pump, fuel pump, plugs, etc., that it would be worth the trade. So out of pure blindness, and ignorance of what to look for, we made the trade.
Took it down to the lake later that day and could not get the thing to run. lol. I was really second guessing my decision. I know at this point that most people would be calling the guy up and demanding that he trade back. But knowing what I might be getting into, I did not. I also know that if I was wanting to check it more I should have before I signed paper work, and bought the boat "as is". I would like to say that I am a man of my word even when others are not. Even though I know I screw up on that at times.
I then decide I will bring it back home and do some deeper looking before I jump to any decisions. I start with sticking a hose on it and starting it up. It starts but then dies. I see water coming out the exhaust, so I feel pretty good about the pump. However, not knowing why it died, I try starting it again. Will not start. After a little bit of checking I come to the conclusion that it is the fuel pump that is not working, because if I take the time to go and prime the carb bowls before trying to start it, it will then start until it runs out of fuel.
Simple enough I thought, I will just order a fuel pump kit, half way expected to have to do that anyways. But, knowing I would be ordering parts, I decided to look at the lower unit. Under close inspection, I notice it is taking on water. Long story short, I order a seal kit for it. I went through the process of taking it back to the place where he had purchased it, seeing how he said it was still under warranty. Which, it was, but they were really lousy people, and it sat long enough "before they could get to it" until it ran out of warranty. However, they said they would honor their warranty, but upon removing the prop they saw fishing line and said that they would not do any more with out payment. Not wanting to fight with them about it I just took the boat home and parked it.
That brings me to this year. I ordered the parts to fix the fuel pump and lower unit last year. Too disgusted with the whole ordeal, I did not even touch it until this spring. I first decided to tackle the lower unit. Did that this last weekend, took it all apart, replaced all the seals, water pump looks good, put her back together and fill with oil. I felt, still feel, confident with it at this point. So with that under my belt I dive into the fuel pump.
That brings me to yesterday. I took the fuel pump apart on Tuesday, noticed that the valves were not working, and one was completely broke, and got on here to ask some questions. Upon looking harder at the situation, and the different posts on here, I decided while I was at it, I had better check the thermostat. That brings me to last night and my quandary.
Hope your still with me at this point. I did not get home till after dark, but I have a work light I used to take the bolts out of the cylinder head and cylinder head cover, which is necessary to take both off to get to the thermostat. Well, just the cover has to be taken off, but in order to take it off, you remove all bolts holding the head on. So they both wind up coming off.
Upon removing the bolts I was noticing that they were corroded at the point where they were in contact with the cylinder head gasket. I thought that it was odd, seeing how the gasket should keep any water away from them, and it was only at that point they were like that. They came out alright though. After that I took the head and cover into the shop to take the cover off to get the thermostat out. After I broke one, of three, of the bolt heads off, I realized that they were corroded also, just a lot more. It was obvious that the head had come off the block, but the cover had not ever come off the head, because the original paint had not been broken from the cover and seal.
I am not too concerned about the bolts, I have removed ones like that before. What concerns me is that when I thought "hey, I'll go look at the cylinders while I got the head off", I did go look, and was sickened by the sight.
What I saw was disgusting. It was dark, but I do not think it is going to look any better in the light when I get home tonight. One cylinder looked good, the middle looked rough, and the bottom looked different than the first two. I will hopefully get some pictures to show soon. The cylinder that concerned me the most (they all do to a degree) was the middle one. It had a few large gouges down the wall running front to back. They were deep enough to catch my finger nails in them.
The reason I make the distinction about them running front to back is because there were others that seemed like, though I cannot say for sure, but they seemed like someone had rotated the drive shaft to bring the piston down as far as they could, for each cylinder, and one by one tried to "hone" the cylinder. The reason I say that is that there are "scratches" that run in a very, very irregular circular direction around the top 1/4th of the cylinders.
So that is where I am at. I am not sure if I should just replace what I have right now, put it back together, and run it like it is until I have time to fix it. It did start and run, But I am willing to bet that it will not have the power of a good cylinder. I am not too concerned with that though at this point. I just want something that will push the boat on the lake to fish with.
My other option is to take it like it is and work on it like it should be. I feel like it is fixable, but I do not know if it is worth the time. If someone has had this issue before I am all ears. Is it worth fixing? What else is there to look for? So on and so forth. Please lay it out for me and let me know what your advice is on this. I think I have covered the questions that may arise, but if not, if there is something else that would help to better give advice, please ask and I will find the information for you.
Thanks guys, I know that there is a world of wisdom on this forum, just hoping that you will impart some on me.