Re: 1957 Evinrude 5.5 Fisherman
I have the cure! (Get BRP replacements, not sierra o-rings, as the sierra are a bit oversized.)
Get a dental pick or 2 from the hardware store. Remove fuel connector from hose, get all fuel sources out of the work area and drain, blow out connector so it's dry. Light a candle, and heat the end of the dental pick. Quickly poke it into the o-ring. Your goal is to melt it through in that spot.. it may take a few heating/poking cycles to get through. Do the same thing to 3 other spots on the same o-ring to break it into manageable bits. Poke the plunger down w/a golf tee, or something non-metal, and pick the bits out.. maybe hold it upside down and shake. This is the only way I've found to get the old, rock-hard o-rings out of the connectors. It may take a while, but you'll get 'em out! Pinch the new o-ring and add a dab of grease to install. Should seat easily.
Good luck!