Buying new motor

pugstori · Jun 3, 2001

Hello..I have a small 11 foot fishing boat that I use in lakes in Colorado. I currently have 2 electric motors and want to buy a small outboard for it. It is rated for a 15 hp motor, but I'm thinking about a 6 to 9.9 (I have to take it off and carry it when I am done). Any ideas on what the best engine would be ?? 2 stroke or 4 stroke ?? We do a lot of trolling. The boat only weighs about 150 pounds. Thanks for the input !!

JB · Jun 3, 2001

Re: Buying new motor

Howdy, Pugstori. I don't know of a water-cooled engine in that range that isn't a wonderful machine. I reluctantly suggest a 2 stroke only because of weight, everything else favors a 4 stroke twin. You probably can't get a 4 stroke twin under 83lb (Evinrude 8hp)while a number of great 2 strokes come in at under 50lb. I have had a number of OMC twins from 3 to 15hp and every one was a great engine. I think the 6 and 8 were my favorite portables. FNR shifting adds weight but is really worth it; otherwise I would favor the 4. Stay with water-cooled twins and you probably can't go wrong with any leading brand. Have fun shopping! JB

pugstori · Jun 3, 2001

Re: Buying new motor

Thanks JB......Do you think that 2 cylinders is very important?? Merc makes a 6hp 4 stroke that only weighs 55 lbs (single though). Otherwise I was thinking that I would go with an 8 hp at 83 lbs if I go with a twin. I would sure rather haul the Merc but I could deal with 83 lbs. Any thoughts ? Thanks !

JB · Jun 3, 2001

Re: Buying new motor

Hi, Pugstori. Yes, I think twins are much smoother than singles, but that is opinion, not fact. Were I in your situation and could stand the idea of lugging 83lb (I am a 65 year-old heart patient) from the car to the boat there is no question that I would favor the Evinrude 8, or equivalent. Congratulations on your guts! Good Luck. JB

pugstori · Jun 3, 2001

Re: Buying new motor

OK J.B., It looks like the Evinrude 8 hp, 4 stroke twin. I am only 36 and my heart is still in decent shape (I think) so I should be ok with the 83 lbs. Isn't the Evinrude made by Yamaha?? I found a website where they have them listed for $1,399 plus freight. What do you think ?? I also thought about a 9.9 but I think that the 8 should move my boat pretty well. Thanks for your input...you have really been very helpful. Take care buddy and I'll let you know how it works out.

JB · Jun 3, 2001

Re: Buying new motor

Hi. I don't know who makes that 'Rude 8. The larger "Evinrude" 4 strokes are made by Suzuki, but Suzi doesn't market a 4 stroke 8 so it could be Yamaha. The price you were quoted sounds to me like an excellent deal if it is the same engine as the 'Rude, or is a different twin. Yamaha is very proud of the light weight of all of their motors, and their reputation is excellent. I would be sure that it is a twin and that it does weigh in at the 83 or less pounds; then I would go for it. Fair sky and flat water. JB

pugstori · Jun 4, 2001

Re: Buying new motor

Hey JB...I just spoke with them and they said that the motor is a '99 model, brand new, no warranty. They said it is a twin but I looked at marineengine.com and it says that it is a single. What do you think ?? I also have this guy calling me with the merc 6hp for $1357 shipped with no tax. The '99 rude 8hp is $1399 plus $200 shipping. Sure is confusing. Thanks again.

JB · Jun 4, 2001

Re: Buying new motor

Yeah, Pugstori, it is confusing. The '99 "Rude" 4 stroke 8 is a single, the 2000 and 2001 brochures offer 8s that are twins. I suspect they were manufactured by different OEMs. The price you were quoted on the '99 is in line with nadaguides. A single, whether it is the 'Rude or the Merc 6, is going to be lighter and "more affordable" than a twin. I would still look for a best price on a 4 stroke twin. Good luck. JB

pugstori · Jun 4, 2001

Re: Buying new motor

Hey JB...another idea. What do you think of the 2000 Johnson 6hp, 2 stroke ?? I saw one new for $999 shipped with a one year warranty. I don't mind mixing the gas and they are light. Are they decent motors ?? Thanks.

pugstori · Jun 4, 2001

Re: Buying new motor

Don't worry JB.....I'm going 4 stroke....thanks again for all of your help. Take care.

pugstori · Jun 4, 2001

Re: Buying new motor

JB...just ordered a 2001 Yamaha 8 hp, 4 stroke, twin. Brand new, in box. Now I have to wait for it....7-10 days. One more week fighting the wind with my electric trolling motors !! Thanks again for all of your input. It was very helpful.

Buying new motor

Cadet

Honorary Moderator Emeritus

Cadet

Honorary Moderator Emeritus

Cadet

Honorary Moderator Emeritus

Cadet

Honorary Moderator Emeritus

Cadet

Cadet

Cadet