Your shifting is actually normal for that era. Having Kiekhaefer on the face dates it as 1960s/early 1970s. The serial number should also be stamped in the motor block near the rear - seven digit number.

As for your waterpump - you will need the serial to get the right impeller - they changed the driveshaft diameters at some point and the serial number will tell you which side of the cutoff you are.

- Scott