You pulled the wrong screw Adam. The screw you pulled holds the shift yoke in place. See if you can fiddle around with the gear shift lever and get the holes to line back up. The drain plug screw is the large one kinda under neath the gear case.


EDIT: If you can lay the motor on it's side, that would help.
__________________
When in doubt...use the manual
Rayland, Ohio....Along the Muddy Banks of the Mighty Ohio River.