Re: Low speed at 4k rpm
Before you make the assumption that the prop is wrong, start making a few checks and simple tests to be sure that you have everything you need to make a decision.
First, don't assume anything.
Now, with the engine OFF, shift into Forward gear and open the throttle fully. Go pull the spark arrester off and LOOK at the throttle plates, are they wide open? While you are there, what size spark arrestor do you have, the four barrel model is taller than the two barrel or it may not pass enough air for the motor to reach full speed under load.
Pull the spark plugs and look at them, are they new, crusty, fouled? How much gap?
What is the compression on each cyl?
Is this a 'points' style ignition? How 'hot' is the spark?
How 'old' is the fuel filter?
Any of these will limit power and can make an engine under perform, falsely causing you to assume the prop to be wrong.
Verify that the engine is capable of performing THEN retest on-the-water to verify WOT RPM before making any prop decisions.