For boats of that age, its more about current condition then boat maker, IMO.
What did and didnt the owners do while they owned them.
Most will agree, entry level Bayliners from the 80s arent the best used boat to buy. Typically not in great shape.
I'd still rather buy a Bayliner, if it was pampered, garage kept when not in use and well maintained by an obsessive owner then any 'expensive/well made' boat that was slipped for extended periods, stored uncovered and generally not well maintained.
Put your hands on all 3, take and post pix of all 3.
Which 2 had surveys?
Who did the surveys, know anyone that knows the surveyors?
Have you read either survey?
IMO, a survey last year is only marginally helpful. Lots can change in a year, esp areas w lots of rain, snow and cold temps.
Good luck