Re: 1948 Scott Atwater Cooling problem
Outside of obvious wear, there isn't much to go wrong with those pumps. Did you install a new rotor (impeller)? If they are swollen they won't work. Other than that, check for wear in the cavity where it runs, and a worn/undersize eccentric cam. Also, the tab on the rotor must be a resonably close fit or it will bypass the outlet water back to the intake side. I believe it is possible to install the anti-cavitation plate upside down, but it won't work because the water holes won't align.
Um...if I remember correctly, there is a right side up to the rotor (slightly tapered).