Re: 1970 Evinrude 85 HP Eletric shift wont start with the key
fred, you said it started with a remote starter button. That means the battery, solenoid, and starter are OK. Furthermore, you went into great discussion about the shift. The shift has absolutely nothing to do with starting. And it will ALWAYS be in gear when not running. So, move on to the real problem.
You seem to have a basic knowledge of testing. What you need to do is first check the fuse. If the electric choke works, the fuse is ok. If not, the fuse is in the red wire, near the starter solenoid. The second thing you need to do is check the voltage at the two small nuts on the starter solenoid while somebody turns the key to start. There should be 12V on one and zero on the other one, and the solenoid should click. If not----
1. Has 12V on both-----the safety switch is bad or misadjusted, or the throttle is advanced too far. The safety switch is there to prevent starting at high throttle settings. It is closed at slow settings, and open at anything above proper starting settings. Note: It also is very easy to damage (burn-out) by improper jump starting. If you accidently connect a full 12V to it, you can't disconnect it fast enough to prevent frying the contacts inside.
2. Has 12V on one and zero on the other one, but solenoid does not click------solenoid is bad
3. No voltage on either when turning the key to start----trouble is ahead of that point. You have to find it with further checks. The current flow is the red wire from fuse to the red connector plug, to key switch, then through the white wire back to the red connector plug and finally to the small nut on the solenoid. Any fault in that route will prevent 12V from reaching the small nut.
4. It is easy to diagnose with some orderly checks. Or you can spend hours and money on it with guessing.