Re: Wiring tach from Johnson controls.
What engine?
What you're describing doesn't add up, unless someone has done some redneck engineering somewhere along the way. The tach signal should be on a grey wire that originates at the rectifier or a terminal block the rectifier is connected to, goes to the remote control, and from there through that 3 pin plug to the tach. The trim signal originates at the trim sending unit and goes up to the trim gauge "S" terminal and it's a white/brown wire. All of this is somewhat generic, but it's similar for all 3 engines that I have manuals for.