how Old was it? Especially the MEKP. How and where was it stored? What were the Temps, Humidity etc... when you did the layup? It's all pertinent to the outcome.
WOG, I don't think Cetol wood finish is supposed to have MEKP added to it.
Does the room w/ heat meet the curing criteria:
Drying Time: To touch: 3 to 4 hrs @ 68°F 65%RH; overcoat: 24hrs.
Was there a jelly in the bottom of an old can of Cetol. I've seen stuff settle out of finishes that have been sitting around before, Esp old finishes that are exposed to repeated heat/cold cycles, like in an unheated storage/garage space. The jelly won't stir back into the finish and often then the finishes won't cure properly after.
Was this the 1st, 2nd or 3rd coat of Cetol? If it was the 1st or 2nd, what, if anything, was applied before the Cetol? Or if it was the 1st or 2nd coat, was the 1st coat applied to bare wood? What type of wood? New/old/perfect wood?
If it wasn't the 1st coat of Cetol, did you sand and prep the existing coat before application of the coat that didn't cure? Did you wipe the surface w/ paint thinner, mineral spirits, acetone or a tack cloth before applying the unccured coat?
Many finishes won't cure properly if applied too heavily.
I suspect the best advice is going to be remove the uncured coat by whatever means necessary.